top of page
American Courtroom

ABOUT ME

Katherine Hartung O'Neal

SENIOR ATTORNEY

Katherine_edited_edited.jpg
Logo (4).png

Bachelor Degree

Shepherd University

Top 1%

Juris Doctorate

West Virginia University

Over fifteen years of experience

Member of the New Mexico Social Security Attorneys Association

Member of the Solo and Small Firm Section

Sustaining Member of the National Organization of Social Security Disability Representatives

Member of the Appellate Practice Section

Track record of excellence in the United States District Court

Member of the State Bar of New Mexico

Member of the Committee on Women in the Legal Profession

Member of the Federal Bar Association

As a New Mexico resident and a West Virginia native, I have seen first-hand the horrors of poverty and have made it my life’s mission to fight for those who cannot fight for themselves.

That mission became more focused after I suffered a severe crushing injury in 2011, leaving me in and out of a wheelchair for three years. Having practiced in the area of social security and workers compensation, at age twenty-nine, I never expected to go through the system as a claimant. My accident, and the surrounding litigation, taught me important lessons on empathy and humility.

Although going back to work while still suffering from disabilities was difficult, my mental perseverance made it possible to thrive in a challenging situation. I was able to take my experiences and use them as fuel to get back to helping people by helping myself. After over five hundred rounds of physical therapy, I was back on my feet and twelve years later, I’m in great mental and physical shape. I appreciate and am thankful for all I’ve been through because it has made me an powerful advocate.

Law Firm

Critical Skills

  • Carefully crafts each argument to the facts and updated law

  • Cognizant of the legal viewpoints of each assigned Magistrate or District Judge

  • Excellent rapport with opposing counsel—friendly, respectful, but tough when necessary

  • Impeccable research skills—strong intellectual curiosity

  • Work well under pressure—calm and efficient

  • Organized—created charts and other documents outlining law

  • Outstanding reputation amongst colleagues—referred cases consistently

  • Incredible passion for helping people living with disabilities

Computers

Armstrong Johnson Law, LLC | Albuquerque, NM

2019-2023

Senior Attorney/Manager Federal Court Department

​Under the tutelage of Attorney Michael D. Armstrong, I learned the art of litigation before the United States District Court for the District of New Mexico (DNM). After his retirement, I received invaluable mentoring and guidance, which allowed me to flourish as a writer. The passion for our clients and unmatched work ethic of his predecessor has inspired me greatly. I was quickly promoted to senior attorney and currently managed the federal court department. I loved hearing work, but my passion was in formulating specialized arguments, targeted to individual magistrates. My job duties are as follows:

  • Represent clients before all levels of the Social Security Administration (SSA)

  • Communicate with the SSA, Disability Determination Services, the Office of Hearing Operations, and the Appeals Council (AC)

  • Craft pre- and post-hearing memorandum, expert objections, creative five-day letters tailored to each client

  • Prepare clients for hearing, explaining the process, basic legal theory, and what to expect from the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)

  • Conduct mock hearings with the client, playing the ALJ and attorney, focusing on fleshing out “bad facts”

  • Explain hearing decisions to clients, going over the next steps regarding payment or appeal

  • Brief Requests for Review to the AC

  • Draft or review Complaints to the DNM

  • Review In Forma Pauperis petitions

  • Oversee all calendaring during the litigation process

  • Write Motions to Reverse and Remand to the Agency or Motions for the Award of Immediate Benefits

  • Proofread and edit every brief that is submitted to the DNM

  • Negotiate conditions of voluntary remand with opposing counsel

  • Serve as point of contact for all communication with the United States Attorney, the Office of General Counsel, and the DNM

  • Analyze DNM Memorandum and Orders for communication with the client and for future use as persuasive authority

  • Draft, negotiate, and file Equal Access to Justice Act motions

  • Draft, confer, and file motions under 42 U.S.C. § 406(b) motions

  • Help prepare briefing before the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

DAVIS MILES MCGUIRE GARDNER, PLLC |
ALBUQUERQUE, NM

2018

Attorney

I was attending a conference for LegalShield, a limited representation service, and met a partner. I was working for another LegalShield provider at the time in rainy and snowy West Virginia. When he asked if I would be interested in employment, I jumped at the chance to escape my arthritic pain. I only worked for Davis Miles for eight months because I had a health scare, and my heart led me back to helping disabled clients

  • Counseled clients on all areas of New Mexico State and Federal Law, including Social Security

  • Wrote demand letters, made calls on members’ behalf, and reviewed and analyzed documents

  • Explained plan coverage to members’ and sales associates

Caldwell and Riffee, PLLC | Charleston, WV

2014-2018

Supervising Attorney

While still recovering from my injuries, I was hired as a part-time attorney with Caldwell and Riffee, a general practice firm that contracted with LegalShield. I was quickly promoted to full-time supervising attorney.

  • Performed duties listed under Davis Miles above

  • Designed and implemented new systems and processes for workflow

  • Assisted with hiring and firing

  • Proposed and implemented cost-saving measures

  • Recruited referral attorneys in the legal community

  • Won multiple awards through LegalShield

  • Implemented a paperless office

The Law Office of Katherine Hartung O’Neal | Charleston, WV

2015-2018

Founder

I built a small practice from referrals received through my work with LegalShield.

  • Practiced in small claims court

  • Reviewed and created contracts for small businesses

  • Defended traffic citations

Jan Dils Attorneys at Law | Parkersburg, WV

2010-2014

Attorney

Under the leadership of the firm’s owner, I represented hundreds of clients at all administrative levels of the SSA. While working with Ms. Dils, I was tasked with learning the writings of Sarah Bohr, studying past NOSSCR conference presentations, and shadowing seasoned claimant’s attorneys. I practiced in the same hearing office as the infamous Eric Conn and was there for the fallout, which gave me a unique respect for the integrity required to practice in this area of the law

  • Performed intakes and helped clients fill out the initial applications, function reports, and reconsideration paperwork

  • Managed a caseload of around forty hearings per month

  • Wrote AC briefs

  • Wrote internal memorandum for the Veterans Benefits department

  • Sang at all firm social events

  • Returned to work in a wheelchair after a catastrophic injury with newly found empathy for our clients

Stamping a Document
Law

Social Security Work Experience

Organizations

  • New Mexico Social Security Attorneys Association

  • National Organization of Social Security Claimants’ Representatives—Sustaining Member

  • State Bar New Mexico

  • West Virginia State Bar (inactive)

  • United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

  • United States District Court for the District of New Mexico

  • United States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia

  • Committee on Women in the Legal Profession

  • Federal Bar Association

  • West Virginia Women Attorneys—Founding Member

  • West Virginia Magistrate Court Mediator

  • CallMeOzz Karaoke Club Premium Member

PRAISE FROM THE COURT

"Ms. O’Neal devotes her primary practice to this specialized area of the law. And her highly effective, successful representation of Plaintiff here reflects the skill and expertise she has developed in Social Security law.” Carrion v. Saul, Civ. No. 19-00204 KK, Order (D.N.M. Jan. 21, 2021)"

Image by Rob Girkin

01. SUBSCRIBE

SUBSCRIBE FOR EXPERT INSIGHTS AND UPDATES STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

FOLLOW US ON :

  • LinkedIn

02. CONTACTS

PHONE

(505) 295-4001

FAX

(505) 448-4079

TOLL FEE

(833) 378-3732

ADDRESS

500 4th Street Northwest, Suite 102 PMB 2909,Albuquerque, NM 87108

​© O’NEAL APPELLATE LAW 2025 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

bottom of page